Christy Clark in hot water over skipping all-candidates debate


Premier Christy Clark is being criticized widely for not participating in an all-candidates debate earlier this week at St. Helen’s Anglican Church in Kitsilano.

During a radio interview today, Clark explained that she’s “too busy running the province” to participate in an all-candidates debate in advance of the Point Grey by-election next week.

The Globe and Mail’s Gary Mason called her out for it yesterday:

But the Premier’s decision not to enter at least one all-candidates debate does not reflect well on her. In fact, it’s a position that demonstrates a fair amount of contempt for the Point Grey voter.

No space in her schedule for a two-hour debate? Really? But she does have time to throw on an apron and pretend to be a waitress for a couple of hours? This, we’re told, so the Premier could “spend a bit of time walking in someone else’s shoes.”


It was a cynical and crass publicity stunt designed to draw attention to the government’s decision to raise the minimum wage – a move for which Ms. Clark deserves full credit. It should have happened a long time ago under the Liberals. She didn’t need to sully a good public policy decision with a blindingly transparent, carefully orchestrated photo-op purely intended to accrue positive publicity.

The Premier has no more appreciation now of the life of a person living on minimum wage than she did before she and her political strategists decided it might be good for her numbers if she served coffee for a couple of hours in a diner. Ms. Clark makes nearly $200,000 a year, plus benefits most people can only dream of. Spend a year on minimum wage, Premier, and your fact-finding mission might not look quite as patronizing.

But back to the debate.

By now, Christy Clark the radio host would have asked Premier Clark what she is afraid of? Why she is refusing to put her candidacy up to the scrutiny of an all-candidates debate? Especially given that the Premier campaigned during the Liberal leadership race on a promise to be more open and transparent. What does she have to lose?

The answer is more than the other guys.

That is why Ms. Clark is not debating; because she has more to lose than anyone else in the debate, especially NDP candidate David Eby. She would inevitably be asked questions that would be uncomfortable. (About her connections to the BC Rail scandal, perhaps.) Plus, a debate would only serve to give Mr. Eby publicity that he is having trouble generating on his own. So why give him that platform?

The answer is because it’s the right thing to do. When you run in an election, you are expected to field questions from your opponents. It is a crucial test of your candidacy. It is practically a fundamental tenet of our democratic system. You don’t say you don’t have time because you’re the Premier. If you can’t find two hours in your schedule to attend an all-candidates meeting, how do you expect to represent the riding once you’re elected?

Do you support Christy Clark in her decision to skip the all-candidates debate? And does Eby have a chance next week? Who are you voting for?

Last modified: May 6, 2011

7 Responses to " Christy Clark in hot water over skipping all-candidates debate "

  1. Ian says:

    My fiancee and I already voted for Eby, and many people that I talked to while door-knocking were very concerned about Clark given here history as education minister.

  2. George says:

    Voted for Eby in advanced voting. Noticed that his signs greatly outnumber Clark’s.

    There’s a photo gallery of the Tuesday debate here:

  3. Derek says:

    I would love to vote for anyone but christy clark. however david eby is a moron. I can’ tin good faith vote for him, no matter how much i’d like to vote NDP

  4. Neil Young says:

    Christy Clark has not demonstrated she’s worthy of my vote, but the unfortunate fact is she’s the lesser of the evils.

    When David Eby’s office called my house this week asking for my support, I asked them why I should support them…..No Answer.

    When Christy Clark’s team knocked on my door (twice within an hour) they asked if they could count on my support and if I had any questions…

    When I asked if it was right I paid $26k in childcare last year, the supporter said they would have someone call me…. But didn’t ask my name or my number.

    Really, they are like all politicians….completely inept. I get better banter from the guy who rents tools at Home Depot!

  5. Toronto Star says:

    Have you changed your mind about either of the candidates since the by-election began? Does it concern you that Premier Clark hasn’t gone to all-candidates debates or is this a non-issue? Did the NDP surge federally impact your decision on who deserves your vote?

    Want to share your thoughts about the riding if you live in the riding?

    Call me. I’m a reporter with the Toronto Star doing a story about this interesting race. 604-739-1917

  6. S. Morris Rose says:

    Eby hasn’t insulted my intelligence (yet?), something I can’t say for Clark.